Challenge Burnett

Opinion

I chose the 27th Ward. I never got to choose its alderman.

A neighbor’s case for a contested election, and how I got here.

By John Nelson · · Updated · 27th Ward resident and small-business owner

Update, Nov. 13, 2026
Five people filed to run for 27th Ward alderman by the Oct. 26 deadline: Ald. Burnett and four challengers. Darlena Williams-Burnett, the alderman’s mother, has filed objections to all four challengers’ petitions, and the Board of Elections is hearing them now. See who filed and where each case stands. The rest of this piece is as published on Oct. 3.
Update, Oct. 7, 2026
I met with Ald. Burnett at ward night on Oct. 6. He told me about problems behind the scenes that I did not know about when I wrote this. Read what happened.

Who I am

I am a transplant, and I will say that first, because it is the first thing anyone in Chicago wants to know. My name is John Nelson. I moved here in 2011 because I got a job offer. That was the whole plan: a job, in a city I had not grown up in.

What I did once I got here was my own decision. I could have worked and left it at that. Instead I decided to work and go to school at the same time, full time at both, and I went to college at Truman College, one of the City Colleges of Chicago, while living in Humboldt Park. I do not say that to impress anyone. I say it because, looking back, I think that decision is when Chicago stopped being a place I had taken a job and started being a place I was building a life.

That was about 15 years ago. Since then I have lived in Humboldt Park, Hermosa, Rogers Park and Buena Park, and since this March in the 27th Ward, which is a decent tour of the north and west sides and, I think, long enough to stop being a visitor. I am a transplant. I am also a Chicagoan, because I decided to be.

In 2019 I started a small tea business, Moody Teas, and since late 2020 I have worked out of a shared commercial kitchen in the 27th Ward. So for about six years this ward was where I worked before it became where I live. That is as much about the business as this piece needs.

I also build software, which is why you will see a second site linked from this piece. When I wanted to know how this ward compares with the other 49, I did not want to rely on anyone’s impressions, including mine, so I built a separate, neutral data site that pulls from the city’s own open data every day and shows its sources. The opinions are here. The numbers there do not argue.

I mention all of this because everything that follows is about choosing. I chose to come to Chicago, chose to spend my first years here working and studying, chose to start a business, and chose this ward, twice. The one thing I never got to choose, and neither did my neighbors, is the alderman.

I should be upfront about my stake. I own a business in this ward and I live in it, which gives me a reason to care how it is run, and a reason you are entitled to weigh. No candidate, committee or campaign is behind this site, and nobody pays for it but me.

Why I moved here

When I decided to live in the 27th Ward, I was excited, and part of the reason was the man who held the seat. Walter Burnett Jr. had been alderman for 30 years, and I considered him an honorable one. I liked the idea of living in a ward led by someone with that kind of tenure.

Then the news came in two parts. In July 2025, he stepped down. In September, Mayor Brandon Johnson named his son, Walter “Red” Burnett, to the seat, and the City Council confirmed him unanimously on Sept. 25. I was perplexed. Handing the seat to the outgoing alderman’s son, with no election, looked like nepotism to me, and I could not square it with the idea that a ward is supposed to choose who speaks for it.

So I tried to learn about him. I looked for anything that could tell me who the new alderman was, and I found very little. He was 29 years old. I did not hold that against him. I respected the family’s pedigree, and I stayed excited about living here.

This March, I moved into the ward. For the first two months I stayed in a temporary place, and in May I moved again. That time I got to choose. I looked for apartments in the ward on purpose, and I focused on the Garfield Park end of it, because my business was already here. I chose the ward. I have now lived in it for most of this year. I have gotten to know the people around me, the blocks near mine, and what the neighborhood has to offer. I liked it, and I still do.

What I saw on Sept. 13

On Sunday, Sept. 13, at about 12:15 in the afternoon, a mass shooting happened on my block.

I did not see it. I saw what came after. A police car was parked outside my back door for hours, and the flashing lights kept me up.

The reporting and the city’s records give the outline. According to police, as reported by Block Club Chicago, six people, including a 14-year-old boy, were standing near an alley on the block when two cars pulled up, and multiple armed people got out and opened fire on the group. All six were shot. One of them, a man, was taken to Stroger Hospital and pronounced dead. Police did not give his age, and the city’s data records him as under 20. A 30-year-old woman was shot while she was in her car, and she crashed into a CTA bus. The others hurt were the 14-year-old boy, an 18-year-old man, and men aged 21, 24 and 26. The 24-year-old was in critical condition. As of the first report, no one had been arrested.

It was not the only shooting that month. In the 15 days from Sept. 8 through Sept. 22, the city’s shooting-victim records show ten people shot within about 0.4 mile of a vacant house on my block, and two of them died. A neighborhood can absorb a lot, and it does, every day. But there is a particular feeling when it happens at your own back door and the lights outside do not stop. The whole neighborhood was on edge, and you could feel it. Nine days after that Sunday, on Sept. 22, police recorded a reckless firearm discharge on my own street.

The alley

I want to tell you what I actually called about, because it was not the shooting. It was the alley behind my building, which kept getting blocked.

The first thing I did was call 311 and tell them the alleys were blocked. A few days later the police were there, the alleys were clear, and I could come home and park my car. For a moment I thought the system had worked. To be fair to it, that call did work.

Then it happened again. A dumpster was sitting in the alley, and my trash can was missing. I called 311 to report that someone had taken my trash can, and 311 transferred me to 911. I told the dispatcher that this did not need 911. We were both confused about what was going on, and the call went badly. She kept asking whether I wanted to make a report. I did want to make a report. I did not want to make it on 911. It was a trash can. I was overstimulated, and I was frightened that I was tying up a line someone who was dying might need, because I wanted to report a stolen trash can. The call got confused, and I never made the report.

I let it go. I kept dealing with it and moving on. Then one day I found the alley blocked so badly that I could not walk my dog through it. I thought: do what you want in your neighborhood, but can I use it? And then I thought about who is supposed to handle exactly this. I called the alderman’s office. An alderman has the connections. He and his staff know everyone in the ward. That is what an alderman is for.

The person who answered spoke as flatly as I have ever heard anyone speak, almost in a mumble. I was stressed. I had been driving around the block trying to find a place to park. I asked to speak with someone, and I will admit I was sharp about it. I was told, more than once, to come in on Tuesday. It was Wednesday, Sept. 30. I asked whether the office has no one who can take a constituent’s question outside of office hours. Then someone walked in who was free to talk. He listened, and he called the police right then, while I was still on the phone. I felt relief. I felt seen.

I watched the dumpster get moved. I left the house to get food for the day, and when I came back the alley was blocked again, this time with a large pallet, the dumpster, rocks and cement blocks. I was back to driving around the block.

The next day, Thursday, Oct. 1, I called again and reached the man who had helped me. I did not catch his name that day or the day before, but I knew it was the same person from his voice: smooth, a staccato baritone, the kind of voice that is comforting. I explained that it had all happened again. He said, “What do you want me to do about it?”

I was heated by then, and I told him to come out and see the problem. As I remember it, he answered, “I bet you would want me to come out there.” Yes. Yes, I would. It is his ward, he is our representative on the City Council, and part of that job is helping us get city resources. I hung up the phone.

Then I did what I do. I put my business-analyst brain to work and gathered all the data I could find about this ward, because I did not see how anyone can serve people better without it. That is when it landed on me that I was dealing with an alderman picked by the mayor from a legacy family, and that this seat needs someone to challenge it. What do you mean, what do you want me to do about it? That is how I got here.

“What do you want me to do about it?”

I do not know the man’s name or his title. I know he answered the alderman’s phone, in the alderman’s office, and that this was the office’s answer to a neighbor asking for someone to come look at an alley. The first time I called, he helped. The second time, he asked me to tell him the job.

I want to be careful about what I am saying. An alderman does not run the police, and I did not ask him to. I asked for someone to come look. I am not saying the vacant house across from me and the shooting are connected, and the city’s records do not say they are. But the vacant house across the alley from my back door has been a problem for a long while, and that alley is where seven people were shot. I did not expect the office to fix all of that. I expected it not to ask me what to do.

Here is what I wanted to hear. I wanted to hear that someone from his office would come to the alley and look at it. I wanted to hear that they would find out who put the dumpster, the pallet and the blocks there, and push the city to clear them and keep them clear. I wanted to hear that they would look at the vacant house and its open building violations, and that someone would tell me when I would hear back. His office can do more than listen. The city’s own 311 records include requests logged by aldermen’s offices, so a ward office can push a ticket, ask for a status, and keep asking. It might not have been able to do all of it. It could have said any of it.

Two shootings, one Sunday

I have thought about what happened elsewhere in the ward that same Sunday morning. At about 1:51 a.m., two men who had been fighting inside a West Loop bar continued the fight in a parking lot a block away, and both fired shots at each other, police told Block Club. A 29-year-old man was grazed on both arms, his jaw and his abdomen. He was taken into custody with a gun and then to Stroger Hospital in good condition. The other man fled.

On Sept. 15, Block Club reported that Ald. Burnett was pushing a parking ban and tougher rules for problem bars in response. He said he plans to introduce an ordinance that month banning parking at metered spots after 11 p.m. on streets like Fulton, Lake and Randolph, and he is drafting another to let the city act faster against businesses that violate their operating plans. “Everyone knows that after 11 p.m. the meters are free,” he told the paper, “and that’s a problem.”

I am not against any of that. An alderman who moves quickly after a shooting is doing a real part of the job. And he made a point in that article that I agree with. He told Block Club that the city’s process against problem businesses can be drawn out, and that it often takes a serious act of violence before a business can be shut down. He is right that waiting for violence is the wrong standard. I would ask him to apply the same standard to buildings and alleys. The vacant house across from me has had four building violations open since December 2019.

That article is about the West Loop, so it would not be expected to mention my block. But I also looked for a public statement from the alderman about the seven people shot there that day, and I could not find one. If he has said something, I would like to read it.

What the city’s records show

One block is only one block, so I did what I would want any neighbor to do and went to the city’s open data, which I compared across all 50 wards as of Oct. 3, 2026. It raises the same questions ward-wide.

Violent crime. The 27th ranks 45th of 50 wards for violent crime reported over the past 12 months: 860 incidents, against 286 in the typical ward. That is down 19% from the year before. Shooting victims fell 26%, to 84, which is still six times the typical ward’s 14. I will say that straight: it is going the right way, and it is still far above almost every other ward. I do not blame the alderman for what happened before he took the seat, and I do not credit him for the improvement either.

The things that stay open. Tickets for fly dumping and sanitation violations stay open past 30 days among the most often in the city, 10.8% and 12.3%, against roughly none in a typical ward, ranking the 27th 50th and 48th. The median pothole ticket here takes 19.3 days to close, against 6.2 in the typical ward, which puts the ward 47th. Traffic signals are reported out again and again: 122 addresses have been reported three or more times in the past year for a signal that was out, against 50 in the typical ward, the most of any ward.

The vacant buildings. Forty addresses in the ward have been reported to 311 as vacant or abandoned three or more times since May 2023, against 12 in the typical ward. Twenty-nine of those 40 have open building violations. One address has been reported 13 times and has 39 open violations dating to September 2021. One of the 40 is the house I have been describing: the city’s records show nine reports to 311 since March 2024 and four building violations open since December 2019. A closed ticket is not a fixed building, and these are the ones that keep coming back.

The money. Each alderman controls a menu budget, $1.5 million a year in the city’s reports, for street, alley, sidewalk and lighting projects. By a volunteer group’s compilation of those reports, the 27th ranked in the top 10 wards for alley resurfacing dollars in nine of the 13 years from 2005 through 2017. From 2018 through 2023 it was not in the top 10 once. I want to be fair about what has happened since. The city’s own reports show alley money rising again: $50,506 in 2023, $132,342 in 2024, $142,076 in 2025, and $241,398 so far in 2026, which ranks 14th of 49 wards. By the city’s third-quarter 2024 report the ward had committed 100% of its menu budget, and by the fourth-quarter 2025 report, 99.1%. “Committed” is the city’s word for money assigned to projects, not money that has produced finished work, and 2026 is not over. The data cannot say why the alley money fell for six years. It can only say that it did, and that it has recently turned.

What he does right. Burnett has been recorded present at every City Council meeting since his appointment. The city closes street light, alley light and graffiti requests in the ward faster than in most wards, and the ward’s overall 311 completion rate, 89.3%, is about typical. I wanted that on the record too.

What I am not saying

I am not accusing the alderman of corruption, and I am not asking anyone to dislike him. I have left his father’s record out of this entirely, because it is not his. I am not blaming him for the shootings. The numbers above do not settle who is responsible for what: the alderman does not control the police or the sanitation department, a 311 report is a report and not a finding, and a busy corridor can produce more reports than a quiet one. This is opinion, and it is mine.

What I am saying is narrower. An alderman has tools, including the menu budget and a ward office that can push tickets, and the pattern of what stays open is a fair thing for the people who live here to ask about. And I am saying that when I asked his office to send someone to look at the alley behind my building, the answer I got was a question.

He has never faced a voter

Ald. Burnett (27th) was appointed by the mayor and confirmed by the City Council on Sept. 25, 2025. That is how Chicago fills a vacancy, and it is legal. It also means that no one in the ward has had a say in who represents them, and the city has no way to recall an alderman.

I think that matters more than people give it credit for. An election is the one time an alderman has to answer all of us at once. In the ordinary course he can answer a constituent with a question and move on to the next call. In a campaign he cannot. He has to sit across from someone who is asking the same thing, in front of the people who live on these blocks, and give an answer they can compare.

The first vote comes Feb. 23, 2027. Petitions have been circulating since July 28, and candidates can file them Oct. 19 through Oct. 26. The seat requires 473 valid signatures. Filing has not opened, so no one has filed, and I have not found anyone who has said they plan to.

What I am asking

A race with one name on it, for a seat held by someone the voters never chose, is a formality, and it should not be one. Whether Burnett has strong answers or weak ones, voters deserve to hear him give them while someone is asking. I moved here because I believed in this ward. I chose it, and I chose it again when it was time to move. I still believe in it, and that is exactly why I think it should have a real election.

Anyone in the ward who thinks the alderman is doing well, or badly, can make that happen by filing. If you disagree with this piece, run and say so. A contested election is better for him, for you, and for every block in the ward.

The steps are not complicated, and they are laid out in a guide on the data site, which also lists who has filed as the Board of Elections reports it. Neighbors who want to document a problem on their own block can report it, keep the request number, and ask the ward office about it. For anyone who would like to help a candidate gather signatures, write to contact@27thwardballot.org.

That night the lights outside my back door kept me up. I would like to live in a ward where the person who holds this seat has answered for what happens on these blocks, to the people who live on them, with a vote behind it.

Sources and notes

The numbers in this piece come from the City of Chicago Data Portal (311 requests, crimes, shooting victims, building violations), the City Clerk’s attendance records, and the city’s Aldermanic Menu Reports, all of which are shown with their methods and caveats on 27thwardballot.org. Alley-resurfacing figures before 2024 come from Ward Wise, a volunteer group, and could not be checked line by line against the city’s PDFs. The Sept. 13 Christiana Avenue shooting: Block Club Chicago. The West Loop shooting and the alderman’s proposals: Block Club Chicago. The appointment: WTTW. What I saw outside my own door, and my calls to 311, 911 and the alderman’s office, are my own account.